DVD Review: Elementary - The Fourth Season

Family matters come to a head for Sherlock Holmes in Season Four of CBS's superior update.

By , Columnist
Given the success of the BBCs modernized Sherlock Holmes and the US networks' record of failing to reinvent British icons for American audiences, its a testimony to the talents involved in Elementary that the series feels as fresh and entertaining in its fourth season as when it first started on CBS back in 2012.

Much of that has to do with the crisp dialogue, the intelligent writing and the leads. Jonny Lee Miller displays sufficient arrogance in his awkward posture and twitching to capture the essence of Conan Doyle's great detective without being idiosyncratic or annoying. This season his manner has also softened enough to maintain Holmes' self-confidence but allow for moments of humility that make the anti-social and emotionally suppressed character someone we can sympathize with.

Elementary_packshot (Custom).jpgWatson, meanwhile, honors Conan Doyle's intent as an intelligent, dedicated friend and the writers never pitch Liu as anything less than an equal partner in the team. As exasperating as Holmes is, especially coming out of the relapse he suffered in Season Three, Watson's support of him never feels forced and the acting and writing ensure there is no need to resort to a degree of attraction to justify their close relationship.

This season also has a recurring role for John Noble as Sherlock's estranged father, Morland. Noble can be equally charming and chilling, which makes him ideally suited to the role of a global mover-and-shaker with fluid ethics. Sherlock's investigation of a past attempt on Morland's life provides a reason for them to interact and the sparkling exchanges between Miller and Noble are standout moments in every episode in which they occur. Thankfully, this subplot intermittently surfaces throughout the season and only towards the end is it revealed whether Morland puts more value on his fortune or his family.

Elementary02 (Custom).jpgIt's true that Elementary's fourth season doesn't stray far from the basic procedural format. Nevertheless, it's a case of intelligence triumphing over formula. Combined with plenty of wit and playful nods to the source material (there is a version of The Hound of the Baskervilles this season, for instance), this ensures that Elementary continues to be more than just a series of mundane murder mysteries

Elementary03 (Custom).jpg

Share this story About the author

Michael Simpson is a freelance writer, editor, presenter, researcher, instructor, gadget freak and sci-tech consultant based in British Columbia’s beautiful Okanagan Valley. Formerly from the UK, he’s converted from tea to coffee and written and presented on film, TV, science, nature, technology,…

View Profile
Visit Website

More from Michael
Related Tags

Connect With TMR

Recent Writers

View all writers »

October 2016
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31