Pirates of the Carribean 4: Johnny Plumbs the Depp-ths, Time to Throw This Sparrow Overboard

Has the time come for Captain Jack to finally walk the plank?

By , Contributor


Johnny Depp had upwards of 30 million reasons to sign on for the new Pirates of the Caribbean outing - co-star Ian McShane suggests Depp is "paid more than the national debt of most countries" - and for that kind of money you'd think he could at least pretend to enjoy wearing Captain Jack's bandana for the fourth time in eight years.

But he doesn't.

Perhaps he's just tired of playing pirate, or maybe he has finally realized the limitations of the swishbuckler, but what was once a sublime characterization has become nothing more than his children's (and their children's) guaranteed annuity. 

An actor as gifted as Depp needs stimulation (and frequently a funny hat, see: Alice in Wonderland, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory) and the sooner he abandons the Pirate ship and leaves the family franchise phase of his career behind the better. It's hard to imagine that Depp is one of the least interesting aspects of this big budget monstrosity, but it's true.
Penelope Cruz, Johnny Depp and Geoffrey Rush -- Disney Pictures

Geoffrey Rush, fresh off his Oscar-nominated turn in The King's Speech, also takes a paycheck here, but at least tries to shiver the timbers. Ditto Ian McShane. Perhaps they're both hoping for some spin-off action once Johnny tires of the whole rigmarole, but at least you can't see them actually reaching for the money. Not that Depp is entirely to blame for the failure of the movie.

Director Rob Marshall shoulders much of the guilt here. People pay money to see the Pirates movies for two reasons: Johnny Depp and the crazy action sequences. The stories have never made any sense, and in that aspect On Stranger Tides doesn't disappoint, but Johnny's disinterest and action scenes that are as exciting as you'd imagine an action sequence directed by the guy who made Nine sink the ship.

When I say failure I mean as a piece of entertainment. This is a guaranteed lock for number one with a BO gross that will make Captain Kidd's legendary buried treasure seem like chump change, but profitability, while important to the suits who green light projects like this, is exactly what's killing Captain Jack.

Guaranteed licenses to print money don't come along very often, but when they do Hollywood often takes a counter-intuitive approach to their cash cows. Why try that hard, Pirates seems to be saying to us, when people will lay down their money no matter if the story is silly, if the picture is so dark you can't see the action, if our star has other things on his mind, if this simply plays like a trailer for the inevitable Pirates of the Caribbean 5: Do You Have Any Money Left? Let's not try to improve or, God forbid, change the formula, the movie gods declare. Let's stay status quo.

Unfortunately status quo kills.

Share this story About the author

Richard Crouse is the regular film critic for CTV's Canada AM, the 24 hour news source CTV's News Channel and the host of In Short on Bravo. He was the host of Reel to Real Canada's longest running television show about movies, from 1998 to 2008 and is a frequent guest on many national Canadian radio…

View Profile
Visit Website

More from Richard
Related Tags

Connect With TMR

Recent Writers

View all writers »

October 2016
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31